The Chamber of St Matthews Old Kentucky Insurance Inc. Share: Insurance Old Kentucky Insurance Inc. Visit Website 915 Lily Creek Road Louisville, KY 40243 (502) 451-8800 (502) 451-8800 (fax) Rep Info Map Whom to Contact Tina Randall 915 Lily Creek Road Louisville, KY 40243 Phone: (502) 451-8800 What's Nearby? Distance: 5 10 15 20 25 50 mi.