The Chamber of St Matthews Sweet Surrender Cafe Share: Bakery Sweet Surrender Cafe Visit Website 1804 Frankfort Ave. Louisville, KY 40206 (502) 899-2008 (502) 899-2990 (fax) About Map About Surrender to our decadent desserts and invigorating espresso. Cakes for every occasion made completely from scratch. Open late, we're the perfect spot for those seeking a unique dessert experience. What's Nearby? Distance: 5 10 15 20 25 50 mi.